Dr. Bendavid Hernia Researcher Tells Parliament Adverse Events are Underreported

Jane Akre
October 27, 2017
Dr. Robert Bendavid, Shouldice Clinic, Toronto

Mesh Medical Device News Desk, October 26, 2017 ~ Dr. Robert Bendavid, of Shouldice Hospital in Toronto, researches hernia repair with polypropylene mesh and studies both mesh and non-mesh repairs and the adverse outcomes.

Because he is so involved in offering research that challenges the established medical societies, he flew to London to participate in Parliamentary debate initiated by the Sling the Mesh Campaign.

During the Parliamentary debate, it is clear that MP (Member of Parliament) Emma Hardy led the way. She says her mail box has been filled with statements from people all around the UK such as:

“Please help me I feel desperate. Who can I turn to to get relief from the terrible irritation and pain I am experiencing. My husband is very worried about my health mentally and bodily, because I keep telling him the quality of my life is dreadful.”​

The government of England has rejected a ban on surgical mesh unlike Scotland that has suspended the use of pelvic mesh since 2014.  While an estimated 8,000 women in England have experienced mesh complications, no one is keeping tabs on the actual number of complications. Many women are told instead that their symptoms are due to "getting old."

Campaigners from Sling The Mesh, July 18, 2017, Cambstimes.co.uk

Like the U.S., there is no active post-approval registry. Adverse events or complications are also not reported by surgeons as Dr. Bendavid enforced in his address to Parliament.

Here is a transcript from the event is recorded in the Hansart here.

Dr. Bendavid tells MND what is needed next.

"As to my trip in London, it was simply to listen to the presentations and debate led by Emma Hardy who passionately defended the women who were victimized by various surgeries (TVT, TVT-O, POP). She did it eminently well. She had the support of many of the MPs present if not all (it was not easy understanding them all!).
"The last to speak was Jackie Doyle Price, who is the undersecretary of Health but also a Minister of Social Affairs, I understand. She stated that “there was not enough evidence to suspend the mesh” and that hopefully, by Christmas, there should be a report.
Emma Hardy, British Labor Party

"The second session was one led by Owen Smith (MP for Ireland and who smart as a whip and very likable) and Emma Hardy. I spoke and so did Carl Heneghan (Oxford and in charge of Evidence Based Medicine) and a stunning lady who was a urogynaecolological surgeon, Dr. Suzy Elneill, who spoke eminently well and drove the message clearly home.

"The message I brought is that not all complications are being reported. A registry has to be mandatory otherwise there would be no collaboration.

"On that subject, the very same Dr David Urbach published a paper proving how little cooperation can be expected from practicing surgeons and why!

"Also, follow-ups are deceiving since complications reported are too soon and we do know that for procidentia* in women, 50% of the problems may occur by 4 years and 8-10 years would be a far better period to assess all patients.

"In hernia surgery, the invasion and erosion which needs explanation of the mesh and vas deferens is usually after 7-13 years. So that if a young man of 18 is to have a bilateral inguinal hernia repair with mesh (as recommended by the EHS “World Guidelines” … by the time he is 30, marries … he may never have a family if he were to plan on one."


*Procidentia - A medical term which has a similar meaning to prolapse, the falling down of an organ from its normal anatomical position. It normally refers to uterine prolapse, but it may also refer to rectal prolapse. From Latin - to fall forward.

British Medical Journal, Factors influencing the reporting of adverse medical device events: qualitative interviews with physicians about higher risk implantable devices, August 2, 2017

Here is a transcript from Parliament : Surgical Mesh Implants - Hansard Online.

Jump to Comments
No items found.

Related to this Article: