Hernia Mesh: The Debate and the History

//Hernia Mesh: The Debate and the History

Hernia Mesh: The Debate and the History

Dr. Robert Bendavid, Shouldice Clinic, Toronto

Dr. Robert Bendavid, Shouldice Clinic, Toronto

In this excellent article by General Surgery News (here)  the history of hernia mesh as well as the present day debate is laid out despite the fact that it is linked to chronic pain, mesh erosion into adjacent tissues or organs, infection and fistulas, among other problems.

General Surgery News reports on the March 2014 annual meeting of the American Hernia Society (AHS).

Dr. Robert Bendavid, MD, is the voice for the thousands of patients who have been harmed by the use of polypropylene mesh.

Dr. Bendavid is with the Shouldice Hospital in Toronto which rarely uses mesh (3%) and is very selective in its indications. Mesh is indicated in femoral hernias, inguinofemoral hernias and even then, the mesh is properly fashioned so that there is minimal contact with any adjacent structures (urinary bladder, femoral/iliac vessels and occasionally vas deferens and fallopian tubes).  Occasionally mesh is used in direct or recurrent direct hernias and most rarely in indirect inguinal hernias. Incisional hernias were not commented upon here.

Dr. Bendavid tells Mesh News Desk, “Although mesh is a necessity in certain surgeries, like incisional hernia repairs, femoral and complex recurrent groin , femoral and complex recurrent groin hernias, the need for mesh in the groin is infrequent. Part of the problem as seen in recurrences is the fact that many surgeons are not familiar with the anatomy of the groin as reflected by the number of missed hernias. There is little need to ever place mesh in the groin or pelvis.” 

Dr. Bendavid questions why use mesh for repairs when it has not lowered the rate of recurrence, especially in women who generally have indirect inguinal hernias and when they have a femoral hernia, their tendency to recur is far less than in men? For every hundred femoral recurrences we see, 80 are in men!

But doctors love to use mesh because mesh companies promote the idea that with mesh you do not need to know your anatomy!  You can create an anatomically correct repair easily with mesh.

At the AHS meeting, Dr. Guy Voeller, MD with the University of Tennessee, stands by a mesh repair as helping many patients and lowering the recurrence rate of inguinal as well as incisional and ventral hernias. Dr. Voeller backs off a bit when he says, “we should shy away from employing a shotgun approach of putting mesh in everyone when sometimes an autogenous repair would work just as well or better.”

An autologous or autogenous repair uses the body’s own tissues harvested from the patient and placed in the area in place of synthetic mesh.

Dr. Bendavid uses a suture only repair in the majority of cases and is among a minority of surgeons to do so. The Shouldice and Bassini repairs are suture hernia repair while mesh used to treat hernias include Kugel, prolene or plug and patch. There are more than 300 types of meshes to choose from).  These are made of polypropylene (PP) and other synthetics can be used such as polyester or ePTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene) or a composite mesh.

Shouldice reports recurrence rates using autogenous inguinal hernia repairs of less than one percent.

One must understand that assessing the success of any surgery includes quality-of-life issues. An anatomically perfect repair that leaves the patient in chronic pain with ongoing infections, would not be considered a success by the patient, though it might be considered a success if the hernia didn’t recur.

The article includes a definition of the Edoardo Bassini , MD repair, considered the father of modern hernia surgery as well as the Shouldice repair technique. Synthetic mesh entered the picture over the past 50 years but only on such a market scale in the last 20 years.

Mesh News Desk’s associate Bruce Rosenberg, himself hernia mesh injured, answers many questions from hernia-mesh injured folks. Reach him at 954-701-5094.

Learn More:

General Surgery News, October 2014, A Century Later Debate on Hernia Repair is Stronger Than Ever,  here

Dr. Robert Bendavid, International Journal of Clinical Medicine, May 2014, Surreptitious Irreversible Neuralgia  or SIN Syndrome,  which is not responsive to treatment, unrelenting and progressive pain

Dr. Robert Bendavid, Uwe Klinge, International Journal of Clinical Medicine, July 2014, Bias-Variation Dilemma Challenges Clinical Trials: Inherent Limitations of Randomized Controlled Trials and Meta-Analysis Comparing Hernia Therapies

Dr. Robert Bendavid, Intl Journal of Clinical Medicine, July 2014,  Hernia Societies- A Blessing or a Curse?

International Journal of Clinical Medicine, July 2014, Editorial on the Status of Hernia Surgery –  Back to Pure Tissue Repair or Forward to Tohubohu, Earl Byrnes Shouldice, See Editorial Here 

By | 2014-10-28T13:37:03+00:00 October 28th, 2014|Medical News|2 Comments

About the Author:

I’m National News Editor, Jane Akre and I began Mesh Medical Device News Desk aka Mesh News Desk (MND) in the summer of 2011 just after the Food and Drug Administration issued an explicit warning to the public that complications associated with surgical mesh used for prolapse repair (POP) and incontinence (SUI) are NOT rare! That was the starting point for the litigation you see today and thousands of lawsuits have been filed by women whose lives have been altered, some permanently, by the use of this petroleum-based product.


  1. Juanita Kennedy February 8, 2015 at 8:54 pm - Reply

    I understand that I may not be as sick as some people but the last 5 years I have been more sick than I have ever been. I also cant say it is al due to the mesh. Five years ago I had mesh put in my abdomin When I awoke from having surgery the doctor told me he put mesh in my belly due to hernias. Since then I have had panic attacks that felt like heart attacks and was hospitalized and various other symtoms. Early 2014 a growth formed on the outside of my skin. Went to my PCP He says it was a hernia and if it started to hurt go to ER.I left it at that. June coming out of work it burst had blood all over my shirt and hands. Went to ER crying and found it was not a hernia but a large ball of infection. The er doctor squeezed it like a pimple( It was as big as a grapefruit). Sent me home with an antibiotic. Was seen by surgeons which opened the area up

    but didn’t find anything. I was seen by them every 2 weeks checking on healing progress. We found another ball coming through and opened it up, it healed with no problem. After 2 or 3 months it hadn’t healed they sent me to another doctor in a bigger city. They said they could see it was infection due to mesh so it had to come out. Went through surgery to take it out and was told there was a trail from the end of the mesh to the center of my belly where it had grew out of my belly. Now am waiting for a third surgery and have not been healthy. I have had so many infections , I cant say that was the cause but if I hadn’t had the antibiotics each time I might have been sepsis and died. I now am being told if I take another day off of work I am fired. I have been looking for a lawyer to help me, but, everyone turns me down. Some say 2 year from time of surgery. It still is infection even after 5 years!!!! Is there a lawyer out there willing to take my case????

    • Jane Akre February 8, 2015 at 10:40 pm - Reply

      Depends on the mesh maker. Please gather all of your medical records including operative and nurses notes. There are some hernia mesh attorneys but very few, again it depends on your manufacturer. You might check with Keller, Jackson who have a small ad on this site. thank you.

Leave A Comment